It's quite commonplace to put the blame on your eye makeup when you end up with irritated, swollen, and itchy eyelids, while the real culprit could be the least suspected one, a nail polish . While it's true that cosmetics for the eyes can cause irritation, even if a person has used the same product for a long time, irritated eyelids and rash can also happen when you accidentally touch your eyelids with stained or unsanitized fingers. The skin on your hands is quite tough and can endure the harshest of chemicals, but not so in the case of eyelid skin. Even a tiny speck of an irritant can bother the delicate skin on the eyelids, be it your eyedrops, your contact lens solution, tiny droplets of hair spray, hair dye, shampoo, conditioner or a tiny speck of wet nail polish.